November 19, 2026
On October 28, the San Marino Planning Commission approved two houses on the same agenda. On Oxford Road, commissioners voted 5–0 to let an owner demolish a 5,836-square-foot house and build an 8,876-square-foot one. On Hampton Road, they also voted 5–0 to approve an 820-square-foot second story, on the condition that the chimney come down by 2 feet 10 inches and that privacy hedges go in along the south side.
So the larger house went through, and the smaller addition had to give up nearly three feet of chimney first. A month earlier, the City Council had upheld the denial of a two-story house on Bradbury Road. That sequence matters to anyone comparing San Marino homes with a remodel in mind. San Marino prices a house as it stands today. The house you plan to turn it into gets decided later, at a public meeting, on grounds that have little to do with square footage.
For the first nine months of 2026, the 91108 ZIP code had a median sale price of $3.2 million. The Pasadena Star-News reported that figure from PropertyShark's annual ranking, which put San Marino at No. 45 among the most expensive ZIP codes in the country. The figure blends houses, townhomes, condominiums and duplexes that closed between January 1 and September 30, 2026.
San Marino sees roughly a hundred single-family closings a year. Over October 2025 through September 2026, that came to fewer than nine a month. At that pace, a single month's median depends heavily on which few houses happened to close. A small cottage on a large lot and a finished estate both count as one sale. Each one's price reflects what a buyer could see and live in on closing day. Neither price includes a second story, a new roofline or a larger footprint that the buyer hopes to add later.
A buyer who stretches for a modest house because of what it might become is paying for that future version up front. The city's fall agendas show how that future version actually gets settled.
Below are the residential cases that went before San Marino's Planning Commission, Design Review Committee and City Council between late August and the end of October 2026. The outcomes come from Citizen Portal's meeting recaps, among them the votes on the pool house on San Marino Drive and the porch enclosure on Cambridge Road.
| Street | What was proposed | Body and date | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hampton Road | 820 sq ft second story, façade changes | Planning Commission, Aug. 26 | Continued for revised plans |
| San Marino Drive | 135 sq ft pool house | Planning Commission, Aug. 26 | Approved 5–0 |
| Oxford Road | Replace 5,836 sq ft house with 8,876 sq ft | Planning Commission, Sept. 23 | Continued 5–0 |
| Bradbury Road | Two-story Prairie-style house | City Council, Sept. 24 | Commission's 4–0 denial upheld |
| Old Mill Road | Replace 1,751 sq ft house with 2,690 sq ft two-story | City Council, Sept. 24 | Appeal approved 3–2 |
| Cambridge Road | Enclose side porch, add bath, about 62 sq ft | Design Review Committee, Oct. 7 | Approved 5–0 |
| Oak Grove Avenue | Reroof with a new shingle | Design Review Committee, Oct. 7 | Continued to Nov. 4 |
| Oxford Road | Same project, revised | Planning Commission, Oct. 28 | Approved 5–0 with conditions |
| Hampton Road | Same project, revised | Planning Commission, Oct. 28 | Approved 5–0 with conditions |
The projects range from a reroof to a full rebuild. In more than one case, the same house came back to a second hearing.
The largest project on the list was approved. The Citizen Portal recap of the Oxford Road approval lists the conditions attached to the 8,876-square-foot house. Two Holly Oaks must stay, the stormwater plan had to be revised, a five-year landscape monitoring program is required, and most of a masonry screening wall will be replaced with wrought iron and hedging. Each condition concerns the trees, the street or the neighbors.
One of the more modest proposals had the hardest time. On Old Mill Road, the plan replaces a 1,751-square-foot house with a 2,690-square-foot two-story. It reached approval only on appeal, by a 3–2 Council vote, after what Citizen Portal described as extensive public testimony on massing and privacy. The approval also came with a construction traffic and parking plan attached.
The Bradbury Road house did not get through. The Planning Commission found that the massing and privacy impacts of the proposed two-story Prairie-style design were not compatible with the neighborhood. The Council affirmed that finding on September 24, and the applicant may submit a new application.
Smaller cases were judged on the same terms. At Hampton Road, commissioners first objected to the proposed dormers, roof pitches and chimney because they added visual mass and departed from the pattern of the street. On Oak Grove Avenue, a reroof was held over after staff found the proposed shingle incompatible with the neighborhood, and committee members asked the applicant to look at alternatives.
All fall, the questions came back to the same four things: how a house's mass reads from the street, what its windows look into, which trees it touches, and whether its roof and materials fit the block.
Approval this fall usually came after revisions. The Oxford Road project was continued on September 23 over planned tree removals and design details. According to Citizen Portal, the homeowner said the plans had already been through seven rounds of revisions. The Hampton Road addition took two months to go from its August 26 continuance to its October 28 approval.
A longer example comes from an earlier case. The San Marino Tribune reported that a remodel on Wilson Avenue entered the city's planning pipeline in 2021. The design went back and forth with the Design Review Committee and Planning Commission, was approved in 2023, and was then appealed. The project was a 287-square-foot one-story addition and a 131-square-foot second story. The oak tree in the backyard became the central question. Under direction from the city's urban forester, the applicant's arborist dug test excavations, and the design moved from a continuous raised foundation to three foundation piers. A tied Council vote then left the Planning Commission's approval in place.
That project added about 418 square feet of living space. The Tribune also reported that the garage's size and its distance from neighbors were part of the dispute, and the garage addition was cut to 74 square feet. Most of the years it took went to the tree and to how the garage sat beside the house next door.
Several of this fall's cases turned on things a buyer can see during a showing. You can note which trees on the lot are large oaks and how close they stand to the part of the house you want to expand. Upstairs windows on either side show where privacy questions would come from if you added a second story. You can walk the block and see whether its rooflines are mostly one story or two, and whether a new dormer or a different shingle would stand out.
A house that already has the room count, the second floor or the layout you need is a different purchase from one that would need a hearing to get there. They are different even when the asking prices match. On the first, you know what you are getting at closing. On the second, the space you are paying for depends on a future vote. Budget for the months of revision that Oxford Road and Hampton Road went through, and for the chance of a result like Bradbury Road's.
None of this is a reason to avoid an older or smaller San Marino house. Four of the projects in the table ended in unanimous approvals, from a 62-square-foot porch enclosure on Cambridge Road to the rebuild on Oxford. The point is to price the house in front of you as the house you are buying.
For a wider look at the city, our San Marino neighborhood page covers the streets and settings these cases sit in. Our buyer's guide covers the purchase steps that come before any design conversation. If financing is part of the equation, our post on jumbo loans in San Marino covers what high-price purchases here usually involve.
How small were the smallest projects on this fall's agendas? A 135-square-foot pool house on San Marino Drive, a roughly 62-square-foot porch enclosure on Cambridge Road and a reroof on Oak Grove Avenue all came before the Planning Commission or the Design Review Committee.
Does a denial end a project? At Bradbury Road, the recap of the Council's September 24 action noted that the applicant may submit a new application.
Is the $3.2 million median a fair guide to a single-family house? It is a useful benchmark for the January through September 2026 period. It also includes condominiums, townhomes and duplexes, so it is a different measure from the price of a detached house on a particular street.
If you are weighing a San Marino house partly for what it could become, Kate Amsbry can walk the property with you and help you price it as it stands today, with the trees, neighbors and street pattern this fall's hearings kept coming back to. Request your complimentary home consultation, and we will start with the house you are actually considering.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Whether you’re mapping out a long-term plan or need to list next month, We're here to listen first, advise second, and guide every step until the ink is dry. Let’s connect—and turn your Pasadena dreams into a solid address.